Roofing Materials
Roofing Material Comparison: GAF vs CertainTeed vs Owens Corning
•
By T&S Roofing Systems
Top Roofing Brands Compared
As a certified installer for GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning, we get asked daily: which brand is best? The truth is, all three manufacture excellent products — but each has distinct advantages. Here's an honest comparison based on our 20+ years of installation experience.
GAF (North America's #1 Roofing Manufacturer)
Best For: Longest warranties, widest selection
Popular Miami Products:
- Timberline HDZ — impact-resistant, Lifetime warranty, most popular choice
- Timberline UHDZ — ultra HD, premium look, exceptional wind resistance
- Grand Sequoia — luxury designer shingles, dramatic shadow lines
Warranty Options:
- Limited Lifetime on shingles — as long as you own your home
- System warranties up to 50 years — materials + labor coverage
- Wind coverage up to 130 mph — or unlimited with LayerLock technology
Pros:
- Most comprehensive warranties — industry-leading coverage through Master Elite contractors
- Master Elite contractor network — only top 3% of contractors qualify
- Largest selection of colors/styles — 50+ color options
- Advanced manufacturing quality control — consistent quality across production
Cons:
- Premium pricing — 10-15% higher than competitors
CertainTeed (Premium Quality, 115+ Years)
Best For: Color selection, sustainable manufacturing
Popular Miami Products:
- Landmark Premium — impact-resistant, excellent color range, algae resistance
- Presidential Shake — luxury designer look, dramatic dimension
- StreakFighter algae resistance — important in humid South Florida climate
Warranty Options:
- Lifetime limited warranty on shingles — transferable coverage
- 10-50 year system warranties available — through SELECT ShingleMaster contractors
- Wind coverage up to 130 mph — with proper installation
Pros:
- Exceptional color palette — best aesthetics in the industry
- StreakFighter algae protection — 25-year coverage (better than competitors)
- SELECT ShingleMaster contractor network — certified professional installers
- Sustainable manufacturing — LEED certified, environmentally conscious
Cons:
- Smaller contractor network than GAF — fewer certified installers
- Fewer budget-friendly options — focus on premium products
Owens Corning (Innovative Technology)
Best For: Advanced technology, value pricing
Popular Miami Products:
- Duration Storm — impact-resistant, excellent value, SureNail technology
- Oakridge — budget-friendly architectural, good warranty
- Berkshire — luxury collection, premium aesthetics
Warranty Options:
- Lifetime limited warranty on shingles — non-prorated coverage
- Platinum Protection warranty — materials + labor through Preferred contractors
- Wind coverage up to 130 mph — with SureNail technology
Pros:
- SureNail Technology — better wind resistance, wider nailing zone
- Best value for performance — competitive pricing with excellent quality
- Pink Panther branding — recognizable quality assurance
- Preferred contractor network — certified installation standards
Cons:
- Fewer color options than competitors — 30-40 colors vs 50+ for GAF
- Less extensive warranty coverage than GAF — good but not industry-leading
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | GAF | CertainTeed | Owens Corning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price Range | $$$ | $$-$$$ | $$ |
| Warranty Coverage | Best | Excellent | Very Good |
| Color Selection | Excellent (50+) | Best (60+) | Good (30-40) |
| Wind Resistance | 130-190 mph | 130 mph | 130 mph |
| Algae Resistance | Good (15 years) | Best (25 years) | Good (10 years) |
Our Recommendation
- Best Overall: GAF Timberline HDZ — best warranty, proven performance, exceptional wind resistance
- Best Value: Owens Corning Duration Storm — great performance at competitive price with SureNail technology
- Best Aesthetics: CertainTeed Landmark Premium — superior color selection and StreakFighter protection
Call T&S Roofing at 305-639-7663 to discuss which brand is right for your home. We'll evaluate your specific needs, budget, and aesthetic preferences to recommend the perfect roofing solution.